In the 11 seasons before Pete Carroll took over the USC football team, the Trojans had a mediocre record of 55-47-3.
Since his debut in 2001, USC is 88-15 with two national championships; three of Carroll’s players are Heisman Trophy winners.
With such a stellar record, one would think Carroll’s hiring by USC would have been a slam-dunk. But after a mediocre tenure (33-31) in the NFL, and nearly two decades removed from coaching at the college level, he was selected only after three other coaches rejected USC’s overtures.
Without Pete Carroll, USC would not be the football powerhouse that it is today. The school's goal of hiring an established college head coach almost cost them dearly, because USC focused on the wrong performance metrics. Many legendary college coaches including Lou Holtz and Steve Spurrier had disastrous NFL careers. But by focusing on Carroll’s NFL record, and not properly appreciating his highly valuable intangible skills regarding recruiting, team building, and leadership, USC favored three lesser candidates first. Fortunately for the Trojans, they lucked into a winner.